«« FanConcert is Presentable (Just in Time) Two Thousand Six »»
blog header image
FanConcert: Stale Scores

FanConcert's scoring system allows people to positively or negatively score other people's posts.

When someone looks at a scored post, like a concert date, they'll be able to see how many people agree or disagree with the post. With this information they'll be able to make a better casual determination of the quality of that information.

Why casual determination? Well, just because a dozen people agree with something doesn't make it true. However it's fair to say it's more likely to be true. In theory all 12 of those people could be malicious but in practise they probably aren't.

I'd like to also look into score weighting in the future. The idea being that the better reputation you have of submitting good information to FanConcert, the greater weight your opinion should have on scoring and editing.

A reputation points calculation for each user is in place for FanConcert right now but it's in the early stages. Many other websites use a reputation point system to gauge how much you should trust a user, like eBay. If you're a FanConcert user your reputation points are on your personal home page.

Back to scoring: a venue could have a negative score because its name is incorrect. What if the person who created that venue fixes the name? The score would still say the name is wrong. This is a problem.

So I'm proposing what I call stale scores. The idea is that all scores submitted before the correction would be marked as stale and the venue's score reset to 0.

The users that submitted those scores would be able to see a list of their stale scores and go back and either re-score the posts or do nothing.

Right now you get reputation points for scoring other people's posts. Stale scores could be worth less than non-stale scores, giving people incentive to revisit stale scores and score the posts again.

Posted at December 22, 2005 at 09:15 AM EST
Last updated December 22, 2005 at 09:15 AM EST
Comments

All this seems way too complicated and time consuming for the average user. Really we just want to be able to post concert information, and look it up. All this scoring stuff is a good idea, because it helps the information to stay accurate. Maybe it would be nice if people could just edit everything at will, with complete chaos, and then allow people to sign up for notifications when things get changed with certain artists or venues. That way, if I was a really big Yanni fan, I could sign up for notifications, and when something was changed/added, i'd get a notification. If it was right, then good. If it was wrong, then I could change it. If I didn't know, I could just leave it alone, and let someone else figure it out, or do a little research and change things if it was found to be wrong.

» Posted by: Kibbee at December 22, 2005 11:22 AM

Notifications by RSS and/or email will be a big part of FanConcert.

As for complexity: the hard part is making a complicated system look simple from the user's persective. I got into technical detail on my blog, but the goal is to make it simple for users.

» Posted by: Ryan at December 22, 2005 11:26 AM
Google
 
Search scope: Web ryanlowe.ca