«« Week 09 Status Report Looking Forward to Metadata »»
blog header image
Bye Bye Hotmail

In the last few months I've slowly changed my main email address from Hotmail to Gmail. It's taken a few months but I think most of my contacts are sending email to the latter now.

By the way, if you would like an invitation for a Gmail account -- currently the only way to get a Gmail account -- then let me know. I have 50 invitations.

Where did Hotmail go wrong from my perspective?

1. I never liked Hotmail's newest interface. I found it too gimmicky and SLOW. Hotmail's old interface was much more useful and fast. Gmail's interface is simple and above all, functional.

2. Hotmail's junk mail protection doesn't work well so I resorted to only accepting emails from contacts. This means I have to keep checking the junk for emails from people not on my contacts. I also had to keep my contact list updated. Gmail's junk mail protection has been very good and I don't have to mess with contacts.

3. It look a long time for my Hotmail account to be upgraded from 2MB to 250MB. Longer than most people I talked to, actually. The order may have been random but I've had my Hotmail account for over 5 years. It would have been nice to have some sort of priority. My Gmail limit stands at 2137 MB and rising and I'm using 169MB of it.

4. Sorting sorting sorting. Hotmail's filtering pales in comparison to Gmail's labels.

5. Gmail's conversation thread handling is a killer feature as far as I'm concerned. Hotmail has nothing like it.

I still have to use my Hotmail email address for MSN Messenger but other than that, I'm outta there.

Posted at April 27, 2005 at 03:31 PM EST
Last updated April 27, 2005 at 03:31 PM EST
Comments

You may have to look around for a while, but there is a way to sign up for passport on your gmail address. I know it's possible but last time I looked it was hard to find. You may want to ask Bernier, he has a non-ms email account hooked up to hotmail.

» Posted by: Kibbee at April 27, 2005 07:10 PM

Yep, you can make a passport with non-Hotmail account. I'm going to keep using the Hotmail account with MSN Messenger so just in case I get emails at the old account, I'll notice them.

» Posted by: Ryan at April 27, 2005 07:20 PM

I have not logged into MSN or hotmail for a while. They have killed my account 2 or 3 times now. I don't loose my contacts, but I loose all my mail. :-|

I don't use hotmail anymore since I only signed up for it 'cause my ISP didn't have web based mail. I think now everyone has web based mail, and like you said, google has the killer app.

» Posted by: Jim at April 27, 2005 08:29 PM

Hotmail is slow.
Gmail is fast.

Anybody with a brain will switch. I use the keyboard hotkeys. My hand never leaves the keyboard. I can manage my email so fast now.

» Posted by: roy at April 27, 2005 11:49 PM

Oooh, oooh! I have a brain!

» Posted by: Ryan at April 28, 2005 03:57 AM

I'll stick with email on my own domain. I really like this because I never have to worry about what happens to my account. I can always have it. I remember when Yahoo used to have POP3 and Forwarding, but then they took that away. Now they just give you lots of space. Although I trust google to play nice, and keep it free forever, you never really know what's going to happen. This is why i stick with using my own domain for mail. It may not have a cool interface like GMail, but I know that I will never have to change addresses again.

» Posted by: Kibbee at April 28, 2005 08:41 AM

I think that if it came to it, I'd pay for gmail... the interface is that wonderful.

» Posted by: Jim at April 28, 2005 09:20 AM

Yes. I sound arrogant. But I've had several emails killed off due to spam. Hotmail was a constant battle for years. Wasted so much time.

» Posted by: roy at April 28, 2005 10:05 AM

I use spamassassin to deal with my spam. It works quite well. In all the time I have been using it (over a year), I've gotten 1 false positive, and 95% of spam doesn't make it to my inbox. My problem with using somebody elses email address is portability. You can't take it with you if you want to leave. If GMail disappears tomorrow, then your screwed. If Gmail decides to start charging, you can change your address or leave. I've gone through 3 or 4 webmail providers and they all pull the same stunt. Give you great features to get you addicted, and then make you pay for stuff you used to get for free. I wouldn't be surprised if Google did this in a few years.

» Posted by: Kibbee at April 28, 2005 01:10 PM

Google's mantra is "Don't be Evil". It's even on their SEC filings. If they ever pulled a stunt like that, it would be considered evil.

I know that wouldn't stop them from pulling the rug out from under us, but when you explicitly say you're not going to be evil it would be insanely stupid to be evil. Having said that, yes I do have a backup plan for email. I have domains and I pay for hosting ... I'm OK.

Just for the record, I'm not getting rid of Hotmail because "Microsoft is evil". I could care less. The Hotmail developers just fell asleep at the wheel and Gmail smoked em.

» Posted by: Ryan at April 28, 2005 01:20 PM

Hotmail has developers? I thought that was something Bill threw together in an afternoon. :)

» Posted by: Kibbee at April 29, 2005 08:53 AM

I know you're kidding but just for people that don't know: Hotmail was originally independently developed and was acquired by Microsoft only a few years ago.

As part of Microsoft's push to put all of their web services under the MSN umbrella, they changed the "original" Hotmail user interface to more closely match their MSN service.

Microsoft also tried to run Hotmail from Windows XP servers instead of *nix (BSD? I'm not sure) but apparently had to rollback the deployment. I'm not sure if they ever succeeded in moving Hotmail completely over to Microsoft servers.

Kibbee's joke is still good though -- there haven't been many obvious improvements to Hotmail features in quite a while so it looks like there's no one working on it any more. But there's plenty of stuff going on under the covers that we don't know about -- especially the recent account size upgrades, which are no small task from a deployment and IT management standpoint.

A little too late I'm afraid. Gmail ate Hotmail's lunch ... and dinner.

» Posted by: Ryan at April 29, 2005 09:07 AM

what about second breakfast?

» Posted by: Jim at April 29, 2005 03:17 PM

Gmail wasn't around for that. ;)

» Posted by: Ryan at April 29, 2005 03:19 PM
Google
 
Search scope: Web ryanlowe.ca